ACG Research

ACG Research
We focus on the Why before the What

Friday, October 19, 2012

Google-Motorola: Can This Marriage Be Saved?

Stock plunge, premature earnings release, Motorola's losses, what more could go wrong for Google?

To say that yesterday was not a good day for Google would be a gross understatement. RR Donnelly, its financial printer, released Google’s Q3 results in the middle of the day (East Standard Time), rather than after the markets closed. In addition to the embarrassing snafu, Google’s profits were well below expectations. Since Wall St. hates surprises, the double whammy caused the company’s stock price to decline 8% on 6 times the normal volume. 

Much of the media attention is focused on the weakness in advertising revenue. Total activity is up, but the cost per click is declining, in part driven by the move to mobile, which commands a lower price and potential competition from Facebook. Only a few analysts and reporters focused on the more than half a billion dollar GAAP loss from Motorola this quarter. 

I have been consistently (since its announcement) saying that the Google-Motorola wedding was not a match made in heaven (read the original blog here). My analysis focused on how Google’s poor track record with hardware, its potential conflict with its customers and how the cultures did not fit. (Yes, I may be wrong in the long term if Google can successfully expand its Kansas City gigabit fiber experiment nationwide and have a captive market for its CPE, but that is a big if). 

The company’s results to date have been validating my position. The Home segment was down over 3% Y-Y, which will likely reinforce its market share losses. Interestingly, my comments about the Home segment were more pronounced for the mobile segment, which was down 27% Y-Y this quarter. Since I do not focus on mobile handsets directly, I did not write much about the mobile segment. In hindsight, this is not a surprising outcome given how competitive the handset space is and how aggressive Samsung has been in its battle with Apple. 

Year-to-Year Change
3Q11
4Q11
1Q12
2Q12
3Q12






Home
-9.5%
-10.3%
-2.2%
-8.4%
-3.4%
Mobile
19.7%
4.7%
3.1%
-24.7%
-27.0%


Google is facing serious issues in its main business and the distractions of a half a billion loss from Motorola, weakness in the handset business, and the slow decline in the home segment are not helping it financially or strategically. Maybe it is time for a divorce? 





David Dines
ddines@acgresearch.net

www.acgresearch.net






No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.